Justia Government & Administrative Law Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
by
A group of parents, authors, a free speech organization, and a book publisher brought a lawsuit against a county school board, challenging the removal of certain library books from public school libraries. The school board had adopted policies, as required by Florida law, mandating the removal of materials deemed pornographic or describing sexual conduct, and established procedures for reviewing objections to specific books. After objections were raised to various titles, review committees and the superintendent made recommendations, and the school board ultimately voted to remove several groups of books based on its existing policies and a directive aligned with state guidelines.Prior to this appeal, the United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida considered whether members of the school board could claim legislative privilege to avoid being deposed about their reasons for voting to remove the books. The district court ruled that legislative privilege did not apply in this context, finding that the board members’ votes to remove specific books constituted administrative acts—applying established policy to particular facts—rather than legislative acts involving the creation or amendment of policy. The district court denied the board members’ motion for a protective order and subsequent motions to quash deposition subpoenas.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed whether legislative privilege shielded the school board members from testifying about their decisions to remove the books. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the district court, holding that the board members’ votes to remove specific books, as applications of existing policy to individual cases, were administrative rather than legislative acts. Therefore, legislative privilege did not bar their depositions regarding those specific removal decisions. The court emphasized its holding was limited to the particular facts of this case and did not address whether other privileges or rules might limit such discovery. View "Pen American Center, Inc. v. Adams" on Justia Law

by
Two attorneys, licensed in New Jersey and Michigan, sought admission to the Florida Bar and challenged a Florida rule requiring applicants admitted to another bar for more than twelve months to pay a higher application fee. They argued that this "experienced-applicant" rule violated the dormant Commerce Clause by burdening out-of-state applicants both on its face and in practical effect. One attorney paid the fee and then sued, seeking a refund and an injunction; the other attorney did not pay and joined the suit to seek prospective relief.The United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida initially dismissed most claims for lack of standing or based on Eleventh Amendment immunity, but allowed a limited practical-effect claim against the executive director of the Florida Board of Bar Examiners. After further amendments and discovery, the district court denied summary judgment to the plaintiffs and granted summary judgment to the executive director, finding that the rule did not discriminate against out-of-state applicants in practice.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the case. It held that the Board of Bar Examiners is an arm of the state and therefore immune from suit under the Eleventh Amendment. As to the claim against the executive director, the court found that the experienced-applicant rule did not facially discriminate against out-of-state applicants, as it was based solely on years of admission, not geographic origin. The court further concluded that undisputed evidence showed the rule imposed similar burdens on both in-state and out-of-state applicants and was adopted for legitimate, non-protectionist reasons. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal and summary judgment, holding that neither facial nor practical-effect dormant Commerce Clause claims could succeed. View "Hernandez v. Florida Board of Bar Examiners" on Justia Law

by
Federal agents executed a pre-dawn raid targeting a gang member in Atlanta, but mistakenly entered the plaintiffs’ residence, three houses away from the intended address and on a different street. The FBI SWAT team forcibly entered, detonated a flash-bang grenade, and detained the plaintiffs, including a minor, before realizing their error and departing. The raid’s leader, Agent Guerra, later attributed the mistake to his personal GPS device, which he discarded shortly after the incident. Plaintiffs disputed the adequacy of pre-raid preparations and alleged multiple torts and constitutional violations.The plaintiffs filed suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, asserting claims against the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) for false arrest, assault and battery, trespass, emotional distress, and negligence, as well as a Bivens claim against Agent Guerra and others for Fourth Amendment violations. The district court granted summary judgment to the United States on most FTCA claims under the discretionary-function exception, and to Agent Guerra on the Bivens claim based on qualified immunity. After an intervening Eleventh Circuit decision, the district court granted judgment to the government on the remaining FTCA claims.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit was instructed by the Supreme Court (following Martin v. United States, 605 U.S. 395 (2025)) to re-examine whether the FTCA’s discretionary-function exception barred the plaintiffs’ claims. The Eleventh Circuit held that the discretionary-function exception shielded the United States from all FTCA claims arising from the raid and affirmed their dismissal. However, the court reversed the grant of qualified immunity to Agent Guerra, finding that, when viewing the evidence most favorably to the plaintiffs, his actions violated clearly established Fourth Amendment law. The case was remanded for further proceedings consistent with these holdings. View "Martin v. USA" on Justia Law

by
Two commercial fishermen and their family business challenged federal regulations that reduced catch limits for gag grouper in the Gulf of Mexico, a fish central to their livelihood. The fishermen argued that the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council, which played a key role in proposing the catch limits and regulatory framework, was unconstitutionally composed and shielded from removal, violating the Appointments Clause and other constitutional provisions. Their complaint alleged significant financial harm resulting from the reduced catch limits.The United States District Court for the Southern District of Alabama found that certain powers granted to the Council—specifically, three statutory “veto” provisions that allow the Council to block actions by the Secretary of Commerce—rendered Councilmembers “officers” wielding significant federal authority. It determined their appointments violated the Appointments Clause because they were not properly appointed as principal officers. However, instead of vacating the catch limit rule, the district court severed the unconstitutional veto provisions from the governing statute and entered judgment for the plaintiffs.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit largely agreed that the Council’s veto powers confer significant authority, so Councilmembers’ appointments as currently structured are constitutionally deficient. However, the Eleventh Circuit held that the remedy should be limited to invalidating actions taken with those veto powers. Because the gag grouper rule was not promulgated using the Council’s unconstitutional veto authority but rather through an advisory process ratified by the Secretary, the rule itself was not tainted. The court vacated the district court’s judgment for the plaintiffs and remanded for entry of judgment in favor of the government, concluding that vacatur of the challenged rule was unwarranted. View "Russo v. Secretary, U.S. Department of Commerce" on Justia Law

by
Delta Air Lines, Inc. and Aerovias de México, S.A. de C.V. sought approval from the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) for a joint venture to provide integrated airline services between the United States and Mexico. DOT approved the joint venture in 2016, granting both approval and antitrust immunity after finding that it would increase competition and public benefits in the U.S.–Mexico aviation market. As part of the approval, DOT required the petitioners to divest certain take-off and landing slots at Mexico City’s airport and imposed a five-year limit on antitrust immunity, citing concerns about slot allocation practices at that airport.After the initial approval, the petitioners operated under these conditions and, in 2022, sought renewal of the joint venture’s approval and immunity. However, DOT issued show-cause orders in 2024, and subsequently a final order in 2025, terminating both the approval and antitrust immunity. The DOT’s decision was based primarily on changes to slot allocation and restrictions on all-cargo carriers by the Mexican government at Mexico City’s airport, which DOT concluded had undermined competition and the public interest. The petitioners challenged this final order in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, arguing that DOT’s decision was arbitrary and capricious.The Eleventh Circuit agreed with the petitioners. It found that DOT had departed from its uniform practice of conducting comprehensive market analyses, instead focusing narrowly on a single airport without adequate explanation. The court also determined that DOT had imposed a requirement for open skies agreement implementation on the petitioners that it had not imposed in similar cases involving other countries. The court held that DOT’s final order was arbitrary and capricious, and vacated the order. View "Delta Air Lines, Inc. v. U.S. Department of Transportation" on Justia Law

by
Two high-ranking officers in a city police department—one the chief and the other the deputy chief of operations—were subject to an internal firearms proficiency assessment. Department policy mandated regular qualifications, and there was confusion over which of two overlapping policies governed discipline for failures. After the deputy chief failed the assessment, she received an extra attempt to qualify, which she passed, and the chief subsequently allowed all failing officers a third attempt. A lieutenant, believing the chief had abused his authority to benefit the deputy chief, filed a complaint with the state ethics commission, prompting an investigation by commission officials.During the investigation, the commission’s special agent and general counsel relied on the allegedly superseded policy, policy 2.311, to argue that the deputy chief faced possible financial penalties and thus had a financial interest in the outcome. There was confusion among department officials and investigators regarding which policy was in effect, and both policies were referenced in departmental communications and disciplinary records. The commission found probable cause of ethics violations by both officers and referred the matter to the state attorney general. However, the attorney general found that the commission officials had relied on false evidence and misrepresentations. An internal review by the commission cleared its officials of wrongdoing.The officers sued the commission’s executive director, special agent, and general counsel in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging due process violations based on fabricated evidence, among other claims. The district court granted summary judgment to the defendants on the federal claims and declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the grant of summary judgment de novo. It held that the officials were entitled to qualified immunity, finding no substantial evidence that they fabricated evidence or acted in bad faith. The court affirmed the district court’s grant of summary judgment for the defendants. View "Finley v. Albritton" on Justia Law

by
A nonprofit organization challenged a decision by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), which approved a request by a fertilizer company to use phosphogypsum—a radioactive byproduct of fertilizer production—in the construction of a pilot road on the company’s private property in Florida. Phosphogypsum is typically stored in stacks due to its emission of radon gas, a known carcinogen. Federal regulations issued under the Clean Air Act generally prohibit its use outside of certain exceptions but allow the EPA to approve other uses if public health is protected as much as it would be by storage in stacks or mines.The EPA, after a multi-year review, found that the company's proposal included all necessary information and that the risks to workers, nearby residents, and the environment were below the applicable health thresholds. The EPA concluded that the road’s use of phosphogypsum posed no greater risk than storage and imposed ongoing monitoring requirements. The nonprofit submitted public comments opposing the approval, arguing that EPA’s action violated regulations and was arbitrary and capricious. After considering these comments, the EPA finalized its approval.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the case. The court first determined that it had jurisdiction because the petitioner had associational standing and the case was not moot. On the merits, the court held that the EPA did not violate its regulations, as the relevant rules unambiguously permit case-by-case approval of “other uses” of phosphogypsum, including road construction, provided health protections are adequate. The court also found that the EPA’s technical review and risk assessment were reasonable and well-supported, and any alleged procedural errors were harmless. The court denied the petition. View "Center for Biological Diversity v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency" on Justia Law

by
Several railroads and industry groups challenged a federal regulation requiring most freight trains to operate with at least two crewmembers unless the use of a one-person crew is shown to be equally safe. The regulation, issued by the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) in 2024, responded to safety concerns about the reduction of train crew sizes as technology advanced, citing specific accidents and research on the importance of crew redundancy for safety. The rule provides exemptions for smaller railroads with established one-person operations and offers a special approval process for others, especially those transporting hazardous materials.Previously, the FRA had declined to regulate crew size, withdrawing a proposed rule in 2019 based on insufficient evidence that one-person crews were less safe. However, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated this withdrawal, criticizing the agency's reasoning and its attempt to preempt state crew-size laws. Following a new rulemaking process, the FRA finalized the 2024 regulation after considering thousands of public comments, a public hearing, and new safety data.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed consolidated petitions from several railroads and associations. The petitioners argued, among other points, that the FRA exceeded its authority, acted arbitrarily and capriciously, failed to adequately consider costs, and violated statutory deadlines. The Eleventh Circuit held that the FRA acted within its broad statutory authority to regulate railroad safety, provided reasonable explanations for its policy changes and regulatory choices, adequately considered evidence and public input, and did not violate the law by taking more than twelve months to finalize the rule. The court denied all petitions for review, upholding the Crew Size Rule. View "Florida East Coast Railway LLC v. Federal Railroad Administration" on Justia Law

by
A student enrolled in a respiratory therapy program at a public university in Georgia was disciplined following an incident during his clinical externship, where he was found responsible for endangering the health or safety of a patient. As a result, the university assigned him a failing grade in his clinical class. The student, who has attention deficit disorder, anxiety, and depression, alleged that university personnel were aware of his conditions. He claimed that prior to the disciplinary hearing, he was denied access to evidence and that the hearing procedures did not comply with the university’s written policies.After exhausting internal university appeals, the student filed a lawsuit in Georgia state court against the Board of Regents and several employees, asserting breach of contract and disability discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act, among other claims. The case was removed to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Georgia. The district court dismissed the breach of contract claim on the basis of state sovereign immunity, finding no enforceable written contract that would waive immunity. The court also dismissed the disability discrimination claims for failure to state a claim, holding that the complaint did not plausibly allege adverse action taken because of the student’s disability.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the case. It held that neither the admission letter nor the student handbook, alone or together, constituted a written contract sufficient to waive Georgia’s sovereign immunity, as neither document set forth all essential terms, especially as to consideration. The court further held that the student’s complaint failed to plausibly allege that the university’s actions were taken because of his disabilities. Accordingly, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal of the student’s breach of contract and disability discrimination claims. View "Waller v. Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia" on Justia Law

by
A city in Georgia experienced ongoing pollution of its property from hazardous substances, including mercury and PCBs, allegedly released as a result of historical industrial operations at a nearby plant site. Georgia Power initially owned the site and later sold it to a Honeywell predecessor, with both companies involved in activities that contributed to the contamination. Over decades, these pollutants migrated into the city’s property and surrounding waterways. In the 1990s, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) intervened and required the companies to investigate and remediate the site’s contamination under its oversight, culminating in a consent decree that obligated the companies to implement EPA’s official remediation plan.The city filed suit in Georgia’s Superior Court of Glynn County, asserting state-law claims for continuing nuisance and trespass, seeking damages and remediation costs. The defendants removed the case to the United States District Court for the Southern District of Georgia, arguing several grounds for federal jurisdiction, including federal officer removal under 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1). The district court rejected all removal grounds and remanded the case to state court, finding that the defendants were not “acting under” a federal officer. The defendants appealed the remand order while litigation continued in state court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit held that it had jurisdiction to review the remand order, finding that the defendants’ notice of appeal triggered an automatic stay of the district court’s remand, rendering subsequent state court proceedings void for these purposes. On the merits, the court held that federal officer removal was proper because the defendants’ remediation obligations arose from and were controlled by the EPA under a consent decree. The court reversed the district court’s remand order, allowing the case to proceed in federal court. View "City of Brunswick v. Honeywell International, Inc." on Justia Law